Classical guitar education since 2010
Home » CGC 008 : John Williams Interview

CGC 008 : John Williams Interview

In this lesson

What keeps John Williams interested in music after decades of performing, recording and collaborating? His answer begins with the pleasure of playing and listening. In this interview with Simon Powis, the classical guitarist discusses a musical life guided by curiosity, encounters with other musicians and the willingness to make decisions for himself.

The conversation challenges the search for a universal method. Williams has strong views about interpretation, teaching and performance, yet repeatedly returns to the need to respond to the particular music and situation. For a learner, this is an invitation to become an active participant in the work rather than waiting for someone else to supply every answer.

Originally published in 2015. These listening notes draw on the recorded conversation. Roles, projects, releases and event announcements refer to the time of recording. Practical reflections are suggested applications, not additional quotations from the guest.

Explore the conversation

Use these approximate timestamps to jump to a topic in the recording.

Ask what draws you to playing

“Do you want to be a guitarist or do you like playing the guitar?”

— John Williams, 7:54

Williams describes following the musical things that interest him. He does not primarily think of this as managing a career; it is the way he lives. The distinction matters when he asks whether a young player is attracted to making music or to the image of being a musician.

Simon brings the discussion to amateurs who play without earning their living from it. Williams recognises the value of that relationship with music. Professional status is not a prerequisite for taking pleasure in the craft or having something to express.

For an adult learner, this can reset the purpose of practice. Improvement can serve the wish to hear a phrase clearly, share a piece with friends or explore unfamiliar music. Those aims have value without being steps towards a professional identity.

Let other musicians widen your musical world

Williams traces his interest in different traditions through particular people and experiences. Meeting Alirio Díaz in Siena introduced him to Venezuelan repertoire and music by Barrios. Jazz was present through his father, while later musical friendships and collaborations expanded that experience.

He also describes London as an environment where different kinds of music and musicians were close at hand. The opportunities mattered because he responded to them. His curiosity extended beyond the guitar community to the sounds and approaches of other instrumentalists.

He is realistic about collaboration: some experiments work better than others. The wish to communicate and make something together remains valuable even when the result is not a complete success. Listening beyond a familiar repertoire can therefore be useful without immediately needing to turn everything you hear into a guitar arrangement.

Learn the music and the technique together

Williams objects strongly to the idea of learning a piece mechanically and adding interpretation afterwards. For him, expression and the physical act of playing belong together from the beginning. Technical decisions make sense in relation to what the music is doing.

This does not mean that difficult movements require no separate attention. It means that a movement is being learned for a musical purpose. Even a slow repetition can have a direction, a relationship between voices or a particular quality of sound.

A practical application is to give a short passage an expressive aim while solving its fingering. Listen for whether the movement supports the phrase. As it becomes more secure, retain the musical reason that led you to work on it rather than waiting until the final stage to consider expression.

Make decisions about memory in context

“we have to get away from thinking in formulas.”

— John Williams, 26:02

Williams describes learning some familiar musical languages through repeated playing, while treating other material more deliberately in sections. Complex contemporary music can create a different challenge: remembering the notes alone may not preserve every detail of rhythm, dynamics and articulation.

He expresses a strong preference for playing much core recital repertoire from memory because of the relationship between performer and audience. At the same time, he gives examples of using the score, including music with unusually detailed notation and a programme whose range made it a practical choice.

These positions belong together in the interview. He is not offering a blanket instruction always to use the score or never to use it. His emphasis is on understanding the musical demands and the purpose of the particular performance. When applying the discussion to your own playing, ask what helps you communicate this piece in this setting.

Grow from imitation towards your own judgment

Williams sees learning to make decisions as an important stage of musical development. A student may begin with guidance and imitation, but eventually needs to decide how a phrase works and why a particular choice is convincing.

His example of copying a famous player’s fingernails makes the point concrete. Seeing another person’s solution can be interesting, yet different hands and nails need different solutions. The same caution applies to adopting another performer’s interpretation as an unquestioned blueprint.

He does not dismiss structured learning. In the discussion of graded examinations, he recognises their preparatory value and the improvements made to them. His concern is that a framework should equip students to act more independently as they develop. Guidance and personal judgment can be successive parts of the same education.

Learn through a room full of listeners

Reflecting on teaching, Williams explains his preference for classes and ensemble situations. Students can hear one another, share impressions and encounter constructive criticism as part of a common learning experience. The person playing is not the only person who can learn.

He relates this to chamber music. Hearing how a viola or clarinet player shapes a phrase may suggest something he can apply to the guitar. Other musicians offer approaches that would be harder to discover by working in isolation.

He acknowledges that individual specialist teaching has a place. The wider lesson is to give listening and exchange a regular role: attend a class, play a duet, or discuss a performance with someone. Being able to explain what you hear can sharpen your own decisions as well as help another player.

Treat teaching as a skill in its own right

“You’re often teaching people who are not going to become professionals.”

— John Williams, 38:14

Simon raises a gap in musicians’ training: many performers will teach for a substantial part of their working lives, yet may receive little preparation for the work of teaching. Williams agrees that helping other people enjoy and understand music requires its own skill.

The conversation questions an old division in which a teaching qualification could amount mainly to a lower performance requirement. Being able to play and being able to teach are related, but one does not automatically supply the other.

For students, this supports looking beyond a teacher’s concert reputation to the learning relationship itself. Can the teacher help you hear, explain the problem clearly and support your own decisions? For teachers, it encourages continuing to study how people learn, including those whose goals centre on enjoyment rather than a career.

Stay open to new ways of sharing music

Although Williams describes himself as someone who does not use computers much, he is enthusiastic about the educational possibilities of online communication. In this 2015 conversation, he sees the potential for recordings, scores and video teaching to reach people who previously had limited access.

He also recognises that teachers will need to develop skills to use the medium well. Greater reach alone does not settle questions of teaching quality. The opportunity is to make meaningful musical exchange possible across distance.

Near the end, he recommends Derek Gripper’s guitar work with African musical traditions, returning to the curiosity that runs through the interview. His interest is not confined to what he already knows how to do. The conversation ends where it began: with listening, discovery and the impulse to engage.

Ideas to take into your own music

These prompts are reflections on the conversation, rather than a routine prescribed by the guest.

  1. Name your reason for playing: choose a musical experience you want from this week’s practice, beyond simply completing a task.
  2. Listen outside the guitar: notice how another instrumentalist shapes a phrase, then consider what you can learn from it.
  3. Make one decision yourself: try two plausible ways of phrasing a short passage and explain which you prefer.
  4. Keep expression in slow work: retain a sense of direction while solving the physical problem.
  5. Share the learning: play for someone, ask what they heard and use that response to inform the next attempt.

Original episode notes and resources

The original introduction and resources are retained below. Any time-sensitive announcements belong to the episode’s publication period.

 

I am really excited to bring you this interview with John Williams. He is an inspirational musician and for many of us, the reason we started playing classical guitar in the first place. John offers some invaluable insights into his approach to music and I found myself listening to the interview several times.

As mentioned in the introduction you can find out more about the online workshop Guitoberfest here: http://guitoberfest.com

Continue exploring

15 thoughts on “CGC 008 : John Williams Interview”

  1. I live in the UK and 30 years ago I got to watch John Williams play live at a local school in a place called Ashington in the North of England, blink and you would drive by it. At the time I was amazed that he would play at such a humble venue, I was told that his daughter and the school masters daughter were at university together and they bullied their ‘Dads’ to put on a show for a local charity.

    He was giving then as he is giving now… some things never change!

    Well done Simon for pulling this off, what a great insight.

    Paul

    Reply
    • John Williams, although I have never met him in person, has always struck me as a very humble and approachable person. I enjoyed the interview and really took home the point that it is ok to
      find your own way as it pertains to playing and learning music. The rigid style of teaching that I
      have been exposed to myself seems only to limit an individual from finding their full expression and potential on the instrument. Well done Simon and John.

      Reply
  2. John Williams is one of the great 20th century guitarist and he presented us with many new music compositions for the guitar.
    He taught students with an open concepts and offer the players with many options. and also improvisations of music. He played the guitar with great musicianship and in depth understanding of the pieces of music.

    Reply
  3. I think John mentioned that a performer or player should able to teach as good as performing skill. However, in actual world it does not seem to match that statement well. I can see that John Williams seldom teach individually besides his teaching for the ensemble group in summer school. he is much involve research new music and play and record new music for guitar.

    Reply
    • He has taught extensively in the past with teaching posts at the Royal College of Music in London and the Royal Northern College of Music in Manchester with whom he still maintains some links but with increasing age he has contracted the time and contact hours that he used to maintain.

      His ideas on teaching are somewhat different from a lot of guitarists which means his ideas have not always been appreciated, least of all by some of his students who complained that he was getting them to play ensemble rather than having one-on-one sessions with him. It led him to resign his position with the Royal College of Music.

      Reply
  4. Thank you so much for this interview Simon. It’s always great to be reminded of the fierce individuality and commitment that John Williams brings to his life pursuits (including interviews!). A pleasure to hear him play on his albums, and a bonus to get the opportunity to hear his opinions as well. Thanks again mate.

    Reply
  5. Wow what a great interview. I have been trying to get time to sit and listen to this interview since it came out and I’ve only just managed to do it. John Williams was the first guitarist to really inspire me when I was a kid and it’s thanks to him I picked up the guitar in the first place. Listening to his views and insights was excellent. Thank you very much Simon for taking the time to organise and conduct the interview. It is very much appreciated.

    Reply
  6. I esp liked John’s point about making decisions for yourself. Methods, theories are a starting point with learning. And there is a whole lot beyond the starting point. I think the finer point behind this is the concept of The Master and The Student. In our contemporary culture, “just following the Master” is a tough sell. I think that the focus on wanting to play music has more longevity: technique, principles, practice, feedback, and asking a lot of questions… that’s what makes a smart and accomplished learner.

    Reply
  7. Thanks for a great interview. John Williams is my favorite guitarist. What was the modern piece he mentioned that started with an N?

    Reply
  8. Well, I have news for John: I learned a lot from looking at his fingernails. I don’t mean that everyone would learn something but if your concept of the guitar is similar to his (I mean naturally and not from any wish to imitate him), it’s certainly possible. Retrospectively and having studied various methodologies, it seems to me that he had intuitively, or maybe by luck, understood something about the three-dimensional geometry that applies to his (and to my) way of playing. So thank you John and thank you for the master classes that I was lucky enough to attend. And please don’t mind showing your fingernails to students – every now and again, it might help someone!

    Reply
    • Hello Sarn,

      I havn’t heard anything from you for decades, but here I am – once again. I have taken a break from guitarplaying for about 20 years, but then some 4-5 years ago I took up plaing again. But something had changed inside me. I no longer liked my Reyes (Cedar/Brazilian) as it seemed my ideals about sound had changed. So I sold the Reyes and in 2015 I got an axcellent Kenneth Brögger ‘Bouchet’, Then again – being very satisfied with the Bouchet, I also got myself a Kenneth Brögger ‘Torres’ SE 144, Both are excellent guitars – excactly to may taste.
      Sarn, what have you been doing all these years? I was going through some of my old notes and found a number of transcriptions and even compositions that you gave me bach in the early 80s. I am going to play it.
      If possible, then please send my a few words. My email: [email protected]
      Best regards
      Finn

      Reply
  9. As ever John Williams the consummate professional and a very orthodox guitarist,for me its Julian Bream as Mr Williams says he and Mr Bream are like chalk and cheese when it comes to playing technique.i think i have my facts right that Mr Bream is mainly self taught although he did work with Segovia and apparently they didn’t get on, was it because of Mr Breams unorthodox style of play?..a maverick,that’s what draws me to Mr Breams work.
    I advise any level of classical guitarist to watch these two geniuses Mr Williams and Mr Bream duet,my favorite is Albeniz “Bajo la Palmera”…a lot to be gleamed from watching them bounce off each others playing style….
    Enjoy…

    Reply
  10. Your own objective of teaching the student to gradually be the driver of their learning process chimes well with the mindset of John Williams.
    The other very important point I got out of the interview is to LOVE playing the guitar as the basis of all my current and future learning.
    Lastly, I’m inspired to be open-minded, curious and encouraged to challenge tradition and to keep exploring different repertoire and types of music.
    Especially with the internet and on line teaching, Simon, the musical world enjoys greater cross fertilisation than ever before.
    Thanks for the invite to listen to this interview.

    Vic Lee
    Sunderand,
    England

    Reply
  11. This is a great interview. I especially like his connection to Joe Pass. I read and listened to numerous interviews with Pass in the last 15 years or so of his life. He said much the same type of things about exploring the instrument, enjoying playing it, and breaking free from the ideas that one play only according to formula.

    Reply

Leave a Comment